Photo by Devon Hawkins on Unsplash
It seemed to come; and then it was gone as quickly. What I am referencing is the referendum in Alberta. Well, the result was clear enough, right. Monday was yet another opportunity for the folks of a Canadian province to express their views: whether to remain in the country, or in this instance to think about a formal vote to determine whether to remain in Canada’s Confederation. As described in the Globe and Mail:
“Roughly 75 per cent of Albertans voted in favour of staying in Canada and 25 per cent for a binding referendum, according to preliminary results from Elections Alberta, which had counted ballots from 90 per cent of voting locations by 7:00 p.m. MT (9:00 p.m. ET) on Tuesday.”
“It marked the failed culmination of decades of effort by disaffected Albertans who have demanded a chance to create their own independent country.”
““I’m very pleased to see the initial results from Elections Alberta show widespread support for remaining in Canada,” Alberta Premier Danielle Smith wrote late Monday on social media. “Albertans have voted for a stronger Alberta in a united Canada.””
And in the Toronto Star the Prime Minister, Mark Carney – possibly breathing just a wee bit of a sigh of relief had this to say:
“Prime Minister Mark Carney hailed the Alberta referendum result as an endorsement of a united Canada as he vowed to work “pragmatically” with provinces on addressing immigration levels and other issues, saying he is open to constitutional reform but only if necessary to effect change.”
Ian Austen from the New York Times had this to say over the Alberta vote:
“Residents of Alberta voted on Monday to remain part of Canada, rejecting a campaign to try to separate the oil-rich western province from the rest of the country. Residents of Alberta voted on Monday to remain part of Canada, rejecting a campaign to try to separate the oil-rich western province from the rest of the country.”
“With just over a third of votes counted, 76 percent of voters chose to remain part of Canada with 23 percent seeking another vote.”
“The referendum reflected the province’s long history of resentment toward the central government but also more recent discontents. Many of the separatist leaders became politically prominent by organizing large protests against restrictions during the Covid pandemic.”
Have we seen this before? Well, no, not in Alberta. But we have seen it ‘in spades’ in Quebec which, not by the way had just voted for a separatist party, and government to now be formed with the Parti Quebecois in Quebec. In fact, the province has held two referendum on sovereignty and separation from Canada in 1980 and then a second in 1995.
As described by David Lukowitz in a brief on separatism in Quebec:
The separatist movement in Quebec is a political and cultural initiative driven primarily by the French-speaking Québécois, aiming to achieve political independence for the province from Canada. The roots of this movement gained significant traction during the Quiet Revolution in the 1960s when the Liberal Party, under Jean Lesage, initiated major reforms that fostered a sense of nationalism among Québécois. This period marked a shift from a conservative, agrarian society toward a more modern, secular, and confident identity that emphasized the importance of preserving the French language and culture.
The movement has had its ups and downs, including two significant referendums in 1980 and 1995, both of which resulted in losses for the separatist cause. Despite these setbacks, the desire for sovereignty has remained strong, leading to the formation of the Parti Québécois and other sovereigntist parties, which have tried to mobilize support, particularly among younger voters.
In the end, the point is that these separatist impulses, today, increasingly appear to be a part of the political fabric of the country. It is somewhat dismaying but I don’t know how else one can read these political forces. I am certainly no expert when it comes to Canadian politics, including its widely divergent provincial politics but it appears very likely such fissiparous impulses are here for now. Will the country remain united? I suspect, yes. But these separatist efforts are not likely to disappear any time soon.
Surprisingly, this week’s second narrative is also about Canada. And this follows the federal government’s efforts to build stronger relationships with countries other than the United States, especially in the face of the current Trump administration. The most notable effort is the steps being considered for a much closer Canada-EU Partnership. As described earlier in the month `by Tonda MacCharles in the Toronto Star:
“A newly revealed leaders’ statement pre-written for next month’s Canada-EU summit does not use “associate member” for the escalating love affair between the Carney government and the European Union.”
“That term, floated by EU Commission President Ursula von der Leyen to Prime Minister Mark Carney‘s apparent surprise two weeks ago in Strasbourg, is nowhere to be seen in the proposed declaration, labelled “as received from Canada,” that was
circulated to EU ambassadors by the European secretariat in charge of talks.”“Now the Canada-EU statement lays out, in black and white, just how Carney is anchoring his ambitions in Europe.”
“It says the two leaders are preparing to announce a stronger “partnership” and it charts deeper Canada-EU co-operation on defence, on artificial intelligence — including a new Digital Trade Agreement — on energy, critical minerals, vaccines and space-based communications — all areas where Canada has historically integrated efforts with the U.S. but areas where Carney has specifically identified strategic
vulnerabilities for Canada. ““The proposed Canada-EU statement pledges to “identify commitments for export of Canadian critical minerals to Europe” and eyeballs the “stockpiling of critical resources to insulate from market fluctuations and geopolitical impacts.””
“That’s despite discussions at the Canada-U.S. trade table about securing preferential U.S. access to Canada’s critical minerals. Remember, that was a big part of the prime minister’s pitch to the U.S. in May, when he said Canada could help “make America
great again.””“Now, according to the draft statement, the Canadian and EU leaders have a different plan. “We will align strategies and standards, connect industries, and focus our ambitions on sectors with greatest returns for our peoples,” reads the document, which solicited European comments by Sept. 28.”
“The joint Canada-EU list of strategic sectors specifies energy, critical minerals and supply chains, semiconductors, vaccines, and space-based communications “where shared resilience is becoming an imperative.””
Leave aside the contentious issue of declaring Canada an associate member of the EU, where there are a number of EU members unhappy or at least unclear at the moment of what that title means but there is a clear desire at least to build a closer EU-Canada trade and investment and security relationship described as an “alliance for the future”. As Steven Chase and Eric Reguly chronicle in the Globe and Mail:
“Canada and the European Union will launch a new “alliance for the future” on trade and defence co-operation at a Montreal summit next week, according to a draft joint statement that also says Canada will be treated as an “associate member” of the 27-country economic bloc going forward.”
“The draft statement was obtained by The Globe and Mail. When finalized, it will be released at the Canada-EU summit to be held Oct. 29 and 30, which will bring together Prime Minister Mark Carney and European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen as they look for ways to reduce economic reliance on the United States.”
“It says Canada and the EU will co-operate to make it easier for businesses and investors to operate across the Atlantic in order to “increase cross-border capital flows, strengthen financial market integration, and improve opportunities for
consumers, financial institutions, businesses and investors.” These efforts, it
adds, will help “mobilize capital for strategic sectors and support long-term
economic growth and competitiveness.””“The plan includes “connecting instant payment systems to facilitate faster, lower-cost and more seamless cross-border transactions,” the draft says.”
“The EU will also invite Mr. Carney to attend a European Political Community meeting in Dublin next month, and the draft statement speaks of “increasingly frequent exchanges with Canadian ministers in relevant Council and ministerial meetings” of the bloc, as well as summits, consultations on policy and regulatory initiatives.”
This summit is almost upon us. It will not be long at all before we can assess how much serious progress in fact has been achieved beyond the rhetoric which we know has been strong in the face of the Trump administration.